As I mentioned many times on this blog, running simulation in parallel using the Parallel Computing Toolbox can save you a lot of time. Today I want to share a few tips to help you getting started with running simulations in parallel.
Serial Parameter Sweep
Before going parallel, let's first look at the standard loop simulating a model. There are tons of ways to setup MATLAB and Simulink to do a parameter sweep. The most common simple setup I see is the following, where we do:
- Load the model using load_system
- Initialize the MATLAB base workspace using a script
- Define a vector of values over which you want to sweep
- Inside the loop, index into the parameter vector
- Simulate using sim
For this example, let's use a simple mass-spring-damper model simulation.
We have an initialization script that initializes three variables.
And we do the parameter sweep using this code.
Simulink and Transparency
When simulating models inside parfor, there are a few intricacies about how parfor manages variables that need to be taken into account. To begin on that topic, I recommend going through the documentation pages about Classification of Variables in parfor-Loops, and Transparency.
Let me resume in a few bullets the important lessons you will learn in those documentation pages:
- Parallel workers are independent MATLAB sessions to which parfor sends code and data to process.
- For efficiency, parfor classifies variables in many categories and sends only the ones it sees as needed
- The code sent to the workers is not executed in their base workspace, but in a special function workspace
- Variables needed by a Simulink model are not "visible" to parfor, and consequently not sent automatically to the workers
- By default, Simulink looks in the base workspace for the variables it needs
Because of those facts, making simulink run inside parfor requires a few tricks. Let's see two techniques to simulate model inside parfor.
Parameter Sweep in the Base Workspace
To be as efficient as possible, we first use an spmd statement to put in the worker's base workspace the data needed by the model that remains constant during the parameter sweep. Then inside the parfor loop, we put in the base workspace the data that changes every iteration, and call sim.
Parameter Sweep in a Function Workspace
In this second technique, we do the opposite. We hide the fact that Simulink is not transparent by doing everything inside a function workspace.
Where the function calling sim sets the SrcWorkspace parameter to point to the current workspace:
Note about the future
Be reassured that we are actively working on features to make simulating models inside parfor easier in the future. However, since we are unfortunately forced to live in the present, I thought sharing some of those intricacies might help a few of you setting up their environment to simulate models in parallel.
Now it's your turn
Try setting up your models to simulate in parallel and let us know how that goes by leaving a comment here.
7 CommentsOldest to Newest
Thanks you for this post and previous post about how to simulate models in parallel.
Currently, I simulate a model (only change parameters) many times in one day. I also use “Simulation Data Inspector” to examine various signals. However, I had also tried to simulate models parallelly with “Simulation Data Inspector”, but it did not work.
May you have a post about how to simulate models parallely with Simulation Data Inspector ?
Thank you very much.
Thank you very much for this very interesting post.
But I’ve got one question: What is the motivation of using the spmd command? I tried your example and it seems to run without it, too.
Ralf, had you run it once before with spmd? If so, the model is still loaded so the subsequent run would not require it. Because the parallel worker has its own workspace, the model needs to be loaded into that workspace. spmd does this.
@Ralf: As Sean describe, SPMD is used to run the things that need to be done only once on the workers. In this example, executing the initialization script needs to be done only once on each worker. Doing it in the simulation loop would add extra cost.
Hello, Thanks for your post. I’m starting with the simulations in parallel, i need that the parameter named L_VC1 vary in the model, i tried with Parameter Sweep in the Base Workspace but i have this error: In an assignment A(I) = B, the number of elements in B and I must be the same.
This is the code:
Do you know why?. Another question, how i should do for take the outputs in my model that I need?.
Thanks for your time. :)
You should be able to work around this problem by enabling the option “Single simulation output” in the “Data Import/Export” section of the model configuration, or by using the syntax simout(i) = sim(mdl,’ReturnWorkspaceOutputs’,’on’).
Can this be used with a model running in External with Simulink Real-Time Windows Target, and one running in Normal mode, and is there any limitation into using results of the external-ran model to the normal-ran model? This to solve compatibility issues with Solvers being used on a Model.