Doug, I am a little confused…I assume x and y are just random coordinates…you then created xd, yd…what is this actually?? How did you do it? Then in linespace you use x,y again, but in interp you use xd,yd. I think I understand the concept, but I’m lost in the details. Can you post all the code so I can run what you did??

@John,

XD and YD are the random points. When used in the interp1 function, XD and YD are the raw data that is then interpolated to the nearest nicely spaced data points in XI.

Make sense?

Doug

Doug, in the linspace functions then you should use xd,yd not x,y…was that just a typo?? If so all makes sense, thx

@John,

I can see where that would work too. For simplicity, I had hidden where the data came from. X and XD both had the same range, so it did not matter.

I had originally planned on showing where the data came, but in production the movie got too long, so it ended on the cutting room floor!

Good catch!

Doug

Sorry, I’m lost. I could not follow what’s happening without the data set to reproduce the example. Fortunately for me, the hist3 function seems to do all the heavy lifting I need.

randx = randn(100000,1);
randy = randn(100000,1);
z = hist3([randx randy],[40 40]);
surf(z)

Doug,

This is a great code! I am also lost though. When I run the line

>> z = accumarray([xr yr], 1, [n n]);

I get the following error:

??? Error using ==> accumarray
Third input SZ must be a full row vector with one element for each column of SUBS.

Also, can you comment how this differs from hist3.m?

@Doug

Please post all the code so I can reproduce it by copying and pasting.

Doug

@dhull

Here is what I was doing to try and duplicate your code:

xd = randn(100000,1);
yd = randn(100000,1);
n=49;
xi = linspace(min(xd(:)),max(xd(:)),n);
yi = linspace(min(yd(:)),max(yd(:)),n);
xr = interp1(xi,1:numel(xi),xd,'nearest')';
yr = interp1(yi,1:numel(yi),yd,'nearest')';
z = accumarray([xr yr], 1, [n n]);
figure(2)
surf(z)

I copied everything save the declarations of xd, yd out of your example in the video. Thanks!

@Douglas,

z = accumarray([xr' yr'], 1, [n n]);

You needed to transpose xr and yr so they are columns when you put them together. The way it was done made them a long row, not two columns. Works fine now!

Doug

@dhull

Thanks! Works great now — very nice code!

I received this error:

Error in ==> testrun at 22
z = accumarray([xr' yr'], 1,[n n]);

Is there anyway to get around this or what is the best way to figure out how to maximize the amount of data without excedding the memory limits?

Thanks,
Doug (Ohio State University)

@Doug,

Without more context, I can not really answer the question. Please contact http://www.mathworks.com/support with all the relevant files to reproduce, and we will take a look at it.

Thanks,
doug

I’m trying to use this function (which I’ve modified below) but I’m getting an error

??? Error using ==> accumarray
First input SUBS must contain positive integer subscripts.

EngSpd & EngTorq are independant 24000 x 1 vectors
SpdBP is a 1×16 vector
TrqBP is a 1×21 vector

Any ideas on how to fix this issue?

Thanks
Colin

xd = EngSpd;
yd = EngTorq;
xi = SpdBP;
yi = TrqBP;
xr = interp1(xi,1:numel(xi),xd,'nearest')';
yr = interp1(yi,1:numel(yi),yd,'nearest')';
z = accumarray([xr' yr'], 1, [length(SpdBP) length(TrqBP)]);
figure(5)
surf(z)

@Colin,

I would put a break point on the line with accumarray. Once stopped in the debugger, figure out what the inputs to accumarray are. It looks like the first one is not what is expected.

Doug

Thanks for the tutorial. Nice thing, I never came up against accumarray which seems to be very useful!

But actually there is a mistake when calculating the BIN-number: since interp1 assigns the nearest value in every dimension, all data points say in x-direction belonging to BIN 1 and half of them in BIN 2 will be assigned to (1,:). Correct should be interpolating to

xr = interp1(xi,0.5:numel(xi)-0.5,xd,'nearest')';
yr = interp1(yi,0.5:numel(yi)-0.5,yd,'nearest')';

which requires

z = accumarray([xr yr] + 0.5, 1, [n n]);

Best
Andrea

@Andrea,

Thank you for catching a subtlety there!

Doug

In the example code, the data from xd will be plotted on the Y axis, and yd on the X axis. To get a properly labeled graph, with the X data along the X axis, you actually need to say:

surf(xi, yi, Z');

Why is that? In the example, we have

Z = accumarray([xr yr], 1, [n n]);

For instance, if something falls in the 1st X-bin and the 5th Y-bin, it will get counted in Z(1,5). But, the MATLAB plotting commands like SURF and CONTOUR take their inputs in the opposite way: To have something show up at (1,5) in the graph, it should be in Z(5,1).

Hope this is useful to the next person who’s thinking sideways!
-Thomas

I made the changes suggested by Andrea and myself, and put them into a nice copy-pasteable (and editable!) file on GitHub:

I am trying to plot out a point spread function, there are positive and negative x and y values and I get this message

??? Error using ==> accumarray
First input SUBS must contain positive integer
subscripts.

any help?

@Jbrand,

You can not pass negative numbers to accumarray. Check your inputs.

Doug

Thanks for the video! I was able to use it effectively for 2 vectors (xd & yd).
I had some other questions about the extent to which I could use this code, or if there are other options available.
1. Is there an alternative to accumarray that will take negative inputs -or am I able to edit accumarray in a way that would allow it to take negative inputs?
2. Is there any way to have such a histogram plot for 3 vectors (xd, yd and zd)? What I would like to have is the x and y coordinates with z as the height and color coded by the frequency distribution. I am basically trying to visualize a special euclidean(2) space (since my z vector lies on polar coordinates). Is there any way to adapt your code to work for 3 vectors in this way?

I know these questions don’t directly apply to the working of the posted tutorial, but any suggestions would be very much appreciated!
Thanks in advance!

I believe I have implemented the 3d analogy for use with a 3d color histogram. Correct me if this is wrong but it seems to be working. Hope this helps someone.

The only issue I have found is displaying this behemoth, since surf() only takes in mxn or mxnx3.

Hi there, I would like to ask if you know how to label the peak values of the data points in your 3D plot. I can’t seem to find any commands in MATLAB that are able to perform that function. Thank you.

Check out the command >>annotation

Hi,

Thank you very much for this post. Its wonderful and exactly what I need to look some 3.5 million data points I have. So I have gone through each comments and details on this page and summarized the code as given below. But I am getting an error “Error using accumarray, First input SUBS must contain positive integer subscripts.” I know there are no negative values in xr and yr, and as suggested I am adding 0.5. So how can I fix it? Please help. Thanks in advance.

x = MAge000(:);
y = DSTS000(:);

% NaN values taken out by
x = x(isfinite(x(:, 1)), :);
y = y(isfinite(x(:, 1)), :);

% Number of bins
n = 49;
xi = linspace(min(x(:)), max(x(:)), n);
yi = linspace(min(y(:)), max(y(:)), n);

xr = interp1(xi, 0.5:numel(xi)-0.5, x, ‘nearest’);
yr = interp1(yi, 0.5:numel(yi)-0.5, y, ‘nearest’);

% [yr xr]: Y then X because the plotting commands take matrices that look like Z(y-coord, x-coord)
Z = accumarray([yr xr] + 0.5, 1, [n n]);

figure(1);
surf(xi, yi, Z);

Hi,
Never mind, I found my mistake, and fixed it. It should be

y = y(isfinite(y(:, 1)), :);

not

y = y(isfinite(x(:, 1)), :);

But I do have a question regarding the selection of n. Why n = 49 and not 50. May be its a stupid question but I dont know/understand. So if you can explain to me will be great.

Thanks again,

Raj

@Raj,

It is an arbitrary number.

Doug

Hi Doug,
This might be a dumb question but before I spend the time to implement this, do you think this will work for an array having 2 million points?
Thanks
-Vipin

d = rand(1,2000000);
hist(d)

2 million is not a big deal to MATLAB.

Hi,
Thank you for your useful codes. My problem is that when I used the code there was an error:
??? Error using ==> interp1 at 125
X and Y must be of the same length.

when I run the codes line by line I noticed that the error happend because of this line in my program:

xr = interp1(xi,1,numel(xi),a,’nearest’)

I clicked on the error and it went through the function named interp1

Do you have any idea why this happened and what should I do?

I would be thankful if you could send me an email.
Regards

Make sure X and Y (The first two inputs) are vectors of the same length. See the doc for interp1.

I am also getting this problem, which I don’t think was ever followed up on:

Error using accumarray
First input SUBS must contain positive integer subscripts.

Yet all of my xr, yr values are positive. I also tried

z = accumarray([round(xr') round(yr')], 1, [n, n],1);

## 33 CommentsOldest to Newest

Good tutorial. This is one type of problem I often find myself trying to solve.

In fact, I find I try to solve it so often that I took the time to write a properly optimized and documented function for the file exchange:

http://www.mathworks.com/matlabcentral/fileexchange/23238-cloudplot

Doug, I am a little confused…I assume x and y are just random coordinates…you then created xd, yd…what is this actually?? How did you do it? Then in linespace you use x,y again, but in interp you use xd,yd. I think I understand the concept, but I’m lost in the details. Can you post all the code so I can run what you did??

@John,

XD and YD are the random points. When used in the interp1 function, XD and YD are the raw data that is then interpolated to the nearest nicely spaced data points in XI.

Make sense?

Doug

Doug, in the linspace functions then you should use xd,yd not x,y…was that just a typo?? If so all makes sense, thx

@John,

I can see where that would work too. For simplicity, I had hidden where the data came from. X and XD both had the same range, so it did not matter.

I had originally planned on showing where the data came, but in production the movie got too long, so it ended on the cutting room floor!

Good catch!

Doug

Sorry, I’m lost. I could not follow what’s happening without the data set to reproduce the example. Fortunately for me, the hist3 function seems to do all the heavy lifting I need.

Doug,

This is a great code! I am also lost though. When I run the line

I get the following error:

Also, can you comment how this differs from hist3.m?

@Doug

Please post all the code so I can reproduce it by copying and pasting.

Doug

@dhull

Here is what I was doing to try and duplicate your code:

I copied everything save the declarations of xd, yd out of your example in the video. Thanks!

@Douglas,

z = accumarray([xr' yr'], 1, [n n]);

You needed to transpose xr and yr so they are columns when you put them together. The way it was done made them a long row, not two columns. Works fine now!

Doug

@dhull

Thanks! Works great now — very nice code!

I received this error:

Error in ==> testrun at 22

z = accumarray([xr' yr'], 1,[n n]);

Is there anyway to get around this or what is the best way to figure out how to maximize the amount of data without excedding the memory limits?

Thanks,

Doug (Ohio State University)

@Doug,

Without more context, I can not really answer the question. Please contact http://www.mathworks.com/support with all the relevant files to reproduce, and we will take a look at it.

Thanks,

doug

I’m trying to use this function (which I’ve modified below) but I’m getting an error

EngSpd & EngTorq are independant 24000 x 1 vectors

SpdBP is a 1×16 vector

TrqBP is a 1×21 vector

Any ideas on how to fix this issue?

Thanks

Colin

@Colin,

I would put a break point on the line with accumarray. Once stopped in the debugger, figure out what the inputs to accumarray are. It looks like the first one is not what is expected.

Doug

Thanks for the tutorial. Nice thing, I never came up against accumarray which seems to be very useful!

But actually there is a mistake when calculating the BIN-number: since interp1 assigns the nearest value in every dimension, all data points say in x-direction belonging to BIN 1 and half of them in BIN 2 will be assigned to (1,:). Correct should be interpolating to

which requires

Best

Andrea

@Andrea,

Thank you for catching a subtlety there!

Doug

In the example code, the data from xd will be plotted on the Y axis, and yd on the X axis. To get a properly labeled graph, with the X data along the X axis, you actually need to say:

Why is that? In the example, we have

For instance, if something falls in the 1st X-bin and the 5th Y-bin, it will get counted in Z(1,5). But, the MATLAB plotting commands like SURF and CONTOUR take their inputs in the opposite way: To have something show up at (1,5) in the graph, it should be in Z(5,1).

Hope this is useful to the next person who’s thinking sideways!

-Thomas

I made the changes suggested by Andrea and myself, and put them into a nice copy-pasteable (and editable!) file on GitHub:

https://gist.github.com/883933

I am trying to plot out a point spread function, there are positive and negative x and y values and I get this message

??? Error using ==> accumarray

First input SUBS must contain positive integer

subscripts.

any help?

@Jbrand,

You can not pass negative numbers to accumarray. Check your inputs.

Doug

Thanks for the video! I was able to use it effectively for 2 vectors (xd & yd).

I had some other questions about the extent to which I could use this code, or if there are other options available.

1. Is there an alternative to accumarray that will take negative inputs -or am I able to edit accumarray in a way that would allow it to take negative inputs?

2. Is there any way to have such a histogram plot for 3 vectors (xd, yd and zd)? What I would like to have is the x and y coordinates with z as the height and color coded by the frequency distribution. I am basically trying to visualize a special euclidean(2) space (since my z vector lies on polar coordinates). Is there any way to adapt your code to work for 3 vectors in this way?

I know these questions don’t directly apply to the working of the posted tutorial, but any suggestions would be very much appreciated!

Thanks in advance!

I believe I have implemented the 3d analogy for use with a 3d color histogram. Correct me if this is wrong but it seems to be working. Hope this helps someone.

colorimage = imread(‘rgb.jpg’);

nbins = 16;

redmat = colorimage(:,:,1);

greenmat = colorimage(:,:,2);

bluemat = colorimage(:,:,3);

ri = linspace(0,255,nbins);

gi = linspace(0,255,nbins);

bi = linspace(0,255,nbins);

rtp = interp1(ri,1:numel(ri),double(redmat(:)),’nearest’);

gtp = interp1(gi,1:numel(gi),double(greenmat(:)),’nearest’);

btp = interp1(bi,1:numel(bi),double(bluemat(:)),’nearest’);

Z=accumarray([rtp,gtp,btp],1,[nbins,nbins,nbins]);

The only issue I have found is displaying this behemoth, since surf() only takes in mxn or mxnx3.

Hi there, I would like to ask if you know how to label the peak values of the data points in your 3D plot. I can’t seem to find any commands in MATLAB that are able to perform that function. Thank you.

Check out the command >>annotation

Hi,

Thank you very much for this post. Its wonderful and exactly what I need to look some 3.5 million data points I have. So I have gone through each comments and details on this page and summarized the code as given below. But I am getting an error “Error using accumarray, First input SUBS must contain positive integer subscripts.” I know there are no negative values in xr and yr, and as suggested I am adding 0.5. So how can I fix it? Please help. Thanks in advance.

x = MAge000(:);

y = DSTS000(:);

% NaN values taken out by

x = x(isfinite(x(:, 1)), :);

y = y(isfinite(x(:, 1)), :);

% Number of bins

n = 49;

xi = linspace(min(x(:)), max(x(:)), n);

yi = linspace(min(y(:)), max(y(:)), n);

xr = interp1(xi, 0.5:numel(xi)-0.5, x, ‘nearest’);

yr = interp1(yi, 0.5:numel(yi)-0.5, y, ‘nearest’);

% [yr xr]: Y then X because the plotting commands take matrices that look like Z(y-coord, x-coord)

Z = accumarray([yr xr] + 0.5, 1, [n n]);

figure(1);

surf(xi, yi, Z);

Hi,

Never mind, I found my mistake, and fixed it. It should be

y = y(isfinite(y(:, 1)), :);

not

y = y(isfinite(x(:, 1)), :);

But I do have a question regarding the selection of n. Why n = 49 and not 50. May be its a stupid question but I dont know/understand. So if you can explain to me will be great.

Thanks again,

Raj

@Raj,

It is an arbitrary number.

Doug

Hi Doug,

This might be a dumb question but before I spend the time to implement this, do you think this will work for an array having 2 million points?

Thanks

-Vipin

d = rand(1,2000000);

hist(d)

2 million is not a big deal to MATLAB.

Hi,

Thank you for your useful codes. My problem is that when I used the code there was an error:

??? Error using ==> interp1 at 125

X and Y must be of the same length.

when I run the codes line by line I noticed that the error happend because of this line in my program:

xr = interp1(xi,1,numel(xi),a,’nearest’)

I clicked on the error and it went through the function named interp1

Do you have any idea why this happened and what should I do?

I would be thankful if you could send me an email.

Regards

Make sure X and Y (The first two inputs) are vectors of the same length. See the doc for interp1.

I am also getting this problem, which I don’t think was ever followed up on:

Yet all of my xr, yr values are positive. I also tried

(in case it needed integers), to no avail.